There are a few reasons why someone might experience oily eyelids. The most common reason is that the person is producing too much oil, which can be caused by several factors such as genetics, hormones, or products that you're using on your face.

Oily Eyelids can make it tricky to find an eyeliner that will stay. What should you look for when purchasing eyeliner if you have oily eyelids? If you have oily eyelids, you'll want to look for a waterproof eyeliner. A lot of liners marketed as "waterproof" are actually only resistant to water, which means they can still smear if you cry or sweat. So when you're looking for a waterproof liner, be sure to check the ingredients list for the word "waterproof" -that is a must when looking for eyeliners for oily lids.

Also, look for an eyeliner that is specifically designed to be long-lasting and resistant to smudging. You'll also want to avoid eyeliners that are creamy or heavily pigmented, as they will tend to smudge more easily. Instead, go for a dry, felt-tip liner that will give you a precise line. Check below to see our picks on the best eyeliners for oily lids.

Loreal Paris Infallible Grip Precision Liquid Eyeliner

-Visible On All Skin Tones

-Sharp Lines That Last Up to 30 Hours

-Waterproof, Smudge + Transfer Resistant

Size:0.03 oz - Vegan ❌ Cruelty Free ✔️

What We Love

This hyper-pigmented eyeliner is affordable and easy to use-making it a breeze to get a really snatched wing. The felt tip makes it easy to draw precise lines whether you want them nice and thin or bold and thick. Reviewers with oily eyelids say this is a holy grail eyeliner as it does not smudge and stays put all day!

Stila All Day Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner

-Dries Quickly

-No Feathering or Running

-Safe for Sensitive Eyes

-Smooth Application

Size:0.016 oz - Vegan ❌ Cruelty Free ✔️

What We Love

This is the perfect liquid liner to draw the thinnest lines. Reviewers loved the “fine marker-like tip” for an easy precise application. Safe for sensitive eyes and ophthalmologist tested. No wonder this line has 4.5 stars on Amazon with over 25, 000 reviews. This liner goes on effortlessly without smudging and lasts all day.

Urban Decay 24/7 Glide on Eyeliner Pencil

-Contains Vitamin E & Jojoba Oil.

-Long-Lasting Color

Size: 0.04 oz - Vegan ❌ Cruelty Free ✔️

What We Love

This is a long-time favorite eye pencil by a lot of reviewers.” Glides on smoothly without pulling eyelid and stays put on all day.” Writes a reviewer. We love that this liner has skin-loving ingredients such as Cottonseed & Jojoba Oil to condition and soften skin. Also, Vitamin E provides moisture and hydration.

Elf Intense H20 Proof Eyeliner Pen

-Precision Felt Tip


-Matte Finish

Size:0.02 oz- Vegan ✔️ Cruelty Free ✔️

What We Love

A felt tip pen that allows you to precisely draw lines that won’t budge, even in the wettest of conditions! With its quick-dry and matte finish, your look will stay in place through day and night. With added Vitamin E to nourish and soften skin. The high pigment formula means the color is long lasting with no smudges or fading. Reviewers with oily eyes and hooded eyes say this liner does not transfer!

Milani Stay Put 16HR Eyeliner

-Built-in Smudger

-Gel Formula


Size:0.01 oz - Vegan ❌ Cruelty Free ✔️

What We Love

Get a sultry smokey look that will last all night with this eyeliner pencil. With a built-in smudger for easy application and error-proof results, this liner is perfect for those who want a flawless cat eye. Cruelty-free and gentle on sensitive skin. Milani Stay Put Eyeliner is a must-have in your beauty routine.

NYX Profession Makeup Epic Inc Vegan Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner

-Precise Tip

-Satin Finish

-Smooth and Bold

Size:0.03 oz - Vegan ✔️ Cruelty Free ✔️

What We Love

This waterproof liquid liner will help you achieve a sexy sharp line effortlessly. Intensely pigmented and waterproof with a satin finish. Reviewers loved the all-day staying power and easy precise application. We love that this liner has a vegan formula and is cruelty-free!

Revlon Color Stay Waterproof Eyeliner

-Built-in Sharpener

-Up to 24 Hours of Wear

-Ophthalmologist Tested & Approved

Size:0.01 oz - Vegan ❌ Cruelty Free ✔️

What We Love

Add some drama and definition to your eyes with this precise, smudge-proof liner. Ultra fine tip with a built-in sharpener. Smooth application without pulling the eyelid and easy to use. "I love how this glides on smooth and I don't have to fuss with it. This is literally the easiest eyeliner to use and its application is flawless" Writes one reviewer. This is your next go-to drugstore eyeliner pencil!

Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Gel Eyeliner

Beauty Binge's Top Pick

Check Price On Amazon

-Gel-Based Formula

-Matte Finish

Size:0.1 oz - Vegan ❌ Cruelty Free ✔️

What We Love

Reviewers have said this is the best smudge proof eyeliner for anyone who has oily skin. Won't budge or fade. No wonder why it's so popular. From its smooth and creamy texture to its bold and beautiful colors, Bobbi Brown has got your back when it comes to creating everyday looks with extreme staying power.


How do you apply gel eyeliner?

Dip a small angled brush into the liner, and then wiggle it back and forth along the ridges to pick up the gel. Glide the brush tip across your lash line, pressing gently to deposit the liner. If needed, go back and re-apply for desired thickness.

Are liquid eyeliners okay to use if you have oily eyelids?

Yes, liquid liners are okay to use if you have oily eyelids. In fact, they can be a good option because they tend to be more long-lasting than other types of liners.

Should you only apply eyeliner to your upper lid?

You can apply eyeliner to your upper and/or lower lid. Some people find it easier to apply eyeliner just to the upper lid, while others find it easier to apply eyeliner to both the upper and lower lid. It's really up to you and what makes it easiest for you to apply the eyeliner.

How We Chose

There are so many products on the market, and they all claim to be the best. We've done the research for you and have saved you time. We have binged on the product reviews on Amazon from people who have already tried them.

When we want to know whether a product is worth buying, we often turn to reviews to get a sense of what other people think. But with so many reviews available, it can be hard to know which ones to trust. When it comes to reviews on Amazon, we take a few different factors into account.

First, we look at the overall rating of the product. If it has a high rating, that's a good sign that people have generally been happy with it. We also pay attention to the number of reviews that have been left. If there are only a handful, it's possible that they're not representative of the broader population.

Finally, we read through the individual reviews to get a sense of what people liked and didn't like about the product. By taking all of these factors into account, we can get a better sense of whether a product is worth buying.

*We do research and read countless reviews for the best products to make our list. If you buy something through our links, we may earn a commission.

‌ ‌

The Best  Eyeliner For Your Oily Lids

And that's it! Thanks for reading! We hope you found this article helpful. Whichever eyeliner you choose, we hope it gives you the eye look of your dreams and stays put all day and night! Thanks for stopping by and happy Shopping!