People love to wear eyeliner because it adds a touch of drama and glamour to their look. From its ancient origins to its modern-day appeal, eyeliner has remained a staple in many makeup collections. Its notable dark hue and ability to create a variety of eye looks is what has kept it relevant for centuries!

Any makeup artist will tell you one of the main reasons why many people turn to eyeliner for their beauty needs is that it helps define the eyes. Whether you're creating a subtle day look or something more intense, eyeliner can be used to emphasize your eye shape and create definition with ease. It's also ideal for making your eyes appear larger or adding unique touches like a cat-eye look that draws attention up and outwards.

Another major draw of this product is its long-lasting power. Unlike regular mascara or eyeshadow, which can smudge or fade after just a few hours, eyeliner offers lasting results often up until you take it off at the end of the day. This makes it incredibly versatile, as it can be relied on no matter what time of day it is applied or what activities are being done in between application and removal. There are numerous types of eyeliners on the market today that offer different colors, textures, and levels of pigmentation — allowing you to customize your look even further. Whether you prefer pencils, liquid liners, gels, or an array of vibrant colors such as blues, greens, purples etc., there's something for everyone!

Finally, if you want to add some flair to your makeup routine without too much effort required — then applying an eyeliner should definitely be considered! Not only does it give you control over how subtle or intense your look becomes but also offers quick changes from day-to-night looks in no time at all!

Overall it’s clear why so many people rely on this classic product when they want their makeup to really stand out; with its long-lasting formulas providing staying power through whatever life throws at them — plus its multitude of color options — anyone who wants their eyes to make an impact need only reach for their favorite eyeliner time after time! Keep scrolling to read our top 8 picks for the best drugstore eyeliners that are affordable, effective, and so-so good!

L’Oreal Paris Flash Cat Eye Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner

-Precision Brush Tip

-Removable Wing Stencil Attached

-Smudge Proof

-Waterproof Eyeliner

Size:0.018 fl oz - Vegan ❌ Cruelty Free ✔️

What We Love

If you are looking to get a precise wing every time, you need this eyeliner. The removable wing stencil that comes with this eyeliner makes doing a sexy classic cat eye quick and easy. Making it perfect for beginners or anyone who doesn’t have a sturdy hand. This formula glides on easy and once it is dry it is locked in for about 8 hours, multiple reviewers wrote. Available in deep black and brown shade with a matte finish. A staple piece to have in your makeup collection for the easiest cat eye. Affordable and long-lasting!

Milani Stay Put Eyeliner

-Up to 16 Hours of Wear


-Built-in Smudger

Size:0.01 oz - Vegan ❌ Cruelty Free ✔️

What We Love

Get a sultry smokey look that will last all night with this brown eyeliner pencil. With a built-in smudger for easy application and error-proof results, this liner is perfect for those who want a flawless cat eye. Cruelty-free and gentle on sensitive skin. Milani Stay Put Eyeliner is a must-have in your beauty routine.

Tip When Using Product

Blur lines with the smudger tool for your desired look.

Maybelline Tattoo Studio Gel Pencil Eyeliner


-Gel Texture

-Versatile & Illuminating

-Slight Shimmer

Size:0.04 oz - Vegan ❌ Cruelty Free ✔️

What We Love

You will be bound to get a lot of compliments with this eyeliner. Maybelline's Tattoo Studio Gel Pencil Eyeliner is perfect for those who want bold, striking eyes that won't smudge. The gel texture glides on smoothly and evenly, giving you versatile and illuminating results. Plus, the slight shimmer adds a touch of glamour to your look.

NYX Profession Makeup Epic Inc Vegan Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner

-Precise Tip

-Satin Finish

-Smooth and Bold

Size:0.03 oz - Vegan ✔️  Cruelty Free ✔️

What We Love

This epic ink liner will help you achieve a sexy sharp line effortlessly. Intensely pigmented and waterproof with a satin finish. Reviewers loved the all-day staying power easy precise application. We love that this liner has a vegan formula and is cruelty-free!

Covergirl Perfect Blend Eyeliner

-Radiant Natural Finish

-Water Resistant

-Plush Blender Tip

Size:0.03 oz - Vegan ❌ Cruelty Free ✔️

What We Love

This liner will give you a precise line for a defined look. If you are wanting a more smokey look, not to worry. It also has a built-in soft angled smudge tip that makes it easy for blending and smudging. Perfect for a quick and easy smokey-eye look. Available in Black brown, charcoal, or basic black.

Almay All Day Intense Gel Eyeliner

-Up to 24 Hours of Color

-Creamy Texture

-Suitable for Sensitive Eyes

Size:0.045 oz - Vegan ❌ Cruelty Free ✔️

What We Love

This gel liner provides a bold stroke of color with just one swipe. Dries instantly and looks just as intense as a liquid liner. Available in 6 different shades so you can play around with multiple colors. One reviewer wrote, "Great product. The color is pigmented and nice, subtle look. Love that it is smudge-proof!"  If you are looking for a gel liner that won't hurt your pockets, this liner is for you.

Neutrogena Intense Gel Eyeliner

-Contains Antioxidant Vitamin E

-Smudge & Water-Resistant

-Soft & Blendable


Size: 0.004 oz - Vegan ❌ Cruelty Free ✔️

What We Love

A highly pigmented formula that goes on smoothly and claims to stay put once dry. Provides a solid lash line that won't melt or crack. We love the added ingredient of Vitamin E to help with smudge resistance and provide antioxidants. The gel/lead is very soft and the color is very vivid. You'll get continuous perfect stokes with this liner everytime.

Tip When Using Product

Only twist up a small amount at a time when using, otherwise, it will break cause the product is so soft.

Revlon Color Stay Waterproof Eyeliner

Beauty Binge's Top Pick

Check Price On Amazon

-Built-in Sharpener

-Up to 24 Hours of Wear

-Ophthalmologist Tested & Approved

Size:0.01 oz - Vegan ❌ Cruelty Free ✔️

What We Love

Add some drama and definition to your eyes with this precise, smudge-proof liner. Ultra fine tip with a built-in sharpener. Smooth application without pulling the eyelid and easy to use. "I love how this glides on smooth and I don't have to fuss with it. This is literally the easiest eyeliner to use and its application is flawless" Writes one reviewer. This is your next go-to drugstore eyeliner pencil!


What is the best way to remove eyeliner?

The best way to remove eyeliner is with a gentle eye makeup remover. Be sure to shake the bottle well before use, and soak a cotton ball or pad in the remover. Place the cotton ball or pad on top of your eyelid and hold it there for about 10 seconds. Then gently wipe the eyeliner off your lid. Repeat as necessary.

Should I use makeup wipes to remove eye makeup?

It's not a good idea to use makeup wipes to remove eye makeup. The ingredients in the wipes can be harsh and irritating, and they may not remove all of the makeup. Instead, use a gentle eye makeup remover that is specifically formulated for the delicate skin around your eyes.

Is it better to wear eyeliner on top or bottom?

A lot of the time it depends on your eye shape. For example, if you have almond-shaped eyes, it looks better to wear eyeliner on the top lid because it brings out the shape of your eyes. If you have round eyes, liner on the bottom lid will make them look more elongated.

Which eyeliner is best, black or brown eyeliner?

It all depends on your eye color!

People with dark eyes might want to try black eyeliner, while those with light eyes might prefer brown. But it's ultimately up to the individual, so you should experiment until you find the color that looks best on you.

How We Chose

We've done the research for you and have saved you time. We have binged on the product reviews on Amazon from people who have already tried them.

When we want to know whether a product is worth buying, we often turn to reviews to get a sense of what other people think. But with so many reviews available, it can be hard to know which ones to trust. When it comes to reviews on Amazon, we take a few different factors into account.

First, we look at the overall rating of the product. If it has a high rating, that's a good sign that people have generally been happy with it. We also pay attention to the number of reviews that have been left. If there are only a handful, it's possible that they're not representative of the broader population.

Finally, we read through the individual reviews to get a sense of what people liked and didn't like about the product. By taking all of these factors into account, we can get a better sense of whether a product is worth buying.

*We do research and read countless reviews for the best products to make our list. If you buy something through our links, we may earn a commission.

The Best Drugstore Eyeliner For You

And that's it! We hope you found this article helpful.

Whichever eyeliner you choose, we hope it helps you achieve the eye-look of your dreams.

Thanks for stopping by and happy shopping!