Brown eyeliner is one of the most popular shades when it comes to eyeliner. It's a great color for people with brown eyes, as it brings out the color of their eyes. Brown eyeliner can also be used to make your eyes pop, or to match your skin tone.

Many people love brown eyeliner because it's a natural shade that can be used for a variety of purposes. It's also a great alternative to black eyeliner, which can be a little harsh on some skin tones. Brown eyeliner is perfect for creating a soft and subtle look, and it's a great way to enhance your eyes.

If you're looking for a new eyeliner color that will complement your skin tone and eye color, then consider giving brown eyeliner a try. You may be surprised at how much you love it!

Keep scrolling to check out our top picks for best brown eyeliners, you will love these beautiful brown shades.

Burt’s Bee’s Nourishing Eyeliner

Best Brown Eyeliner with Natural Ingredients

Check Price On Amazon

∼Contains Jojoba Oil & Mango Oil

∼Safe for Sensitive Eyes

∼Ophthalmologist Tested

∼Smear Resistant

Size:0.04 oz - In the Shade Warm Brown

What We Love

Compliment your eyes with this beautiful brown shade.

This liner is perfect for those with sensitive eyes, as it is ophthalmologist tested. Contains Jojoba Oil and Mango Oil in the formula help to nourish your skin. This liner is smear resistant, so you can enjoy your beautiful look all day long!

Tip When Using Product

Start at the inner corner of the eyelid when applying.

NYX Mechanical Eyeliner Pencil

∼Vegan & Cruelty Free

∼Highly Pigmented

∼Twist Up Pencil


Size: 0.01 oz - In the Shade Bronze

What We Love

NYX's Mechanical Eyeliner Pencil is the perfect tool for creating any look - from a natural daytime look to a dramatic smokey eye. This highly pigmented pencil glides on smoothly and evenly, and its waterproof formula ensures that your look will last all day. Reviewers have said this is the best pencil for water lines!

Tip When Using Product

Works great for water lines!

Maybelline Unstoppable Eyeliner

∼Up to 24 Hours of Wear

∼Mechanical Pencil


∼Suitable for Sensitive Eyes

Size:0.01 oz -In the Shade Cinnabar

What We Love

This liner is a mechanical pencil style with a bold, defining tip that is also smudge proof and squint proof. So no matter what your day or evening holds, you can count on your eyeliner staying put. It is also waterproof and suitable for sensitive eyes, making it a great option for those with allergies. The beautiful Cinnabar color is perfect for a lighter complexion.

Tip When Using Product

Start at the inner corner of the eyelid when applying.

Benefit Cosmetics Roller Liner Matte Liquid Eyeliner

∼Precision Felt Tip

∼Quick Dry

∼Matte Finish

∼Glides Smoothly

Size: 0.03 oz - In the Shade Brown

What We Love

With its precision felt tip, quick dry formula and matte finish, it's perfect for creating dramatic cat eyes that will last up to 24 hours. This brown liner glides on smoothly for easy application. Great for beginners or making thin lines to the lash line. Will not tug or drag on skin. The matte finish provides a great finish.

Tip When Using Product

Pairs great with Roller lash curling & lifting mascara for a dramatic bold look!

Physicians Formula Ultra-Fine Liquid Eyeliner + Serum

Best Multi-Use Eyeliner

Check Price On Amazon


∼Lash Boosting Complex

∼Cruelty Free

∼Enhances the Appearance of Lashes

Size:0.03 oz - In the Shade Deep Brown

What We Love

The Lash Boosting Complex and hypoallergenic formula make this eyeliner ideal for those with sensitive skin or who are looking for a natural way to boost their lashes. The Ultra-Fine Liquid Eyeliner + Serum enhances the appearance of lashes with its nourishing and conditioning properties. Made with a cruelty-free formula, this liquid eyeliner goes on smoothly and evenly, providing precise application for a perfectly defined look. So if you're looking for an eyeliner that is gentle, effective, and lash-enhancing, this is the one for you.

Tip When Using Product

Apply to base of lashes for lash boosting effect.

Sila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner

Best Brown Liquid Eyeliner

Check Price On Amazon

∼Quick Dry

∼Beginner Friendly

∼Matte Finish

∼Easy Application

Size: 0.016 oz - In the Shade Dark Brown

What We Love

Of course the Sila Eyeliner had to make the list.. this has been a cult favorite for the long time. And for good reason! Celebrity makeup artist love this eyeliner. With quick drying and beginner friendly properties, this eyeliner is perfect for anyone who wants to achieve the perfect winged eye look. This is a beautiful dark brown eyeliner that we truly feel will become one of your favorites.

Tip when Using Product

Always shake well before use.

NYX Jumbo Eye Liner

Best Light Brown Eyeliner

Check Price On Amazon

∼Multi-Use Pencil

∼Creamy Texture


∼No Pulling, Tugging or Fading

Size: 0.18 oz- In the Shade Iced Mocha

What We Love

This is a creamy multi-use pencil. Can be used as a liner, eyeshadow or a primer. Reviewers loved its versatility and the fact that it is extremely affordable! The shade Iced Mocha, is perfect for anyone looking for a pop of light brown color to add to their eyes.

Tip When Using Product

Can also be used as an eyeshadow.

Milani Stay Put Eyeliner

Beauty Binge's Top Pick for Best Brown Eyeliner

Check Price On Amazon

∼Up to 16 Hours of Wear


∼Built in Smudger

∼Cruelty Free

Size:0.01 oz - In the Shade Semi Sweet

What We Love

Get a sultry smokey look that will last all night with this brown eyeliner pencil. With a built in smudger for easy application and error-proof results, this liner is perfect for those who want a flawless cat eye. Cruelty free and gentle on sensitive skin. Milani Stay Put Eyeliner is a must-have in your beauty routine.

Tip When Using Product

Blur lines with the smudger tool for desired look.


Who should wear brown eyeliner?

There is no "one size fits all" answer to this question, as the best way to wear brown eyeliner depends on your eye color and skin tone. However, as a general rule, brown eyeliner can be worn by anyone who wants to add warmth and depth to their eyes.

If you have light eyes, try a light brown or tan liner. If you have dark eyes, try a darker brown liner. And if you have medium skin tone, experiment with different shades of brown until you find the perfect one for you.

Which eyeliner is best black or brown eyeliner?

It all depends on your eye color!

People with dark eyes might want to try black eyeliner, while those with light eyes might prefer brown. But it's ultimately up to the individual, so you should experiment until you find the color that looks best on you.

How do you do subtle brown eyeliner?

Subtle brown eyeliner can be achieved by using a light brown shade on the upper lid and a dark brown or black shade on the lower lash line. You can also use a dark brown or black eye shadow to create a subtle cat eye look.

How do you wear brown eyeliner?

Brown eyeliner can be applied in a number of ways, depending on the look you're going for. You can line your entire eye with it, or just the bottom lash line; you can create a thin or thick line; and you can make it bold or subtle.

One of the most popular ways to wear brown eyeliner is to tightline your eyes. This involves lining the waterline (the inner rim of your eye) with brown liner, which makes your eyes look bigger and more awake. Another great way to use brown liner is to create a smoky eye look. Just mix a little bit of brown liner with some black shadow, and you'll have a dramatic new look.

How We Chose

We've done the research for you and have saved you the time. We have binged on the product reviews on Amazon from people who have already tried them.

When we want to know whether a product is worth buying, we often turn to reviews to get a sense of what other people think. But with so many reviews available, it can be hard to know which ones to trust. When it comes to reviews on Amazon, we take a few different factors into account.

First, we look at the overall rating of the product. If it has a high rating, that's a good sign that people have generally been happy with it. We also pay attention to the number of reviews that have been left. If there are only a handful, it's possible that they're not representative of the broader population.

Finally, we read through the individual reviews to get a sense of what people liked and didn't like about the product. By taking all of these factors into account, we can get a better sense of whether a product is worth buying.

*We do research and read countless reviews for the best products to make our list. If you buy something through our links, we may earn a commission.

The Right Brown Liner For You

And that's it! We hope you found this article helpful.

Whichever eyeliner you choose, we hope it helps you achieve the eye-look of your dreams.

Thanks for stopping by and happy shopping!